Detroit Works Project
Our Future. Now.
  • Home
  • About
    • Project Team
      • Acknowledgements
    • Contact
    • Media Kit
  • Engagement
    • Events
    • How To Engage
    • Stay Informed
    • Provide Feedback
    • What You Said
      • Community Comments
    • Engagement Report
    • Engagement Map
    • Toolkits
    • Community Conversations II
    • Community Conversations I
      • Conversation 01
      • Conversation 02
      • Conversation 03
    • Detroit 24/7
      • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Telephone Town Hall
  • The Framework
    • Detroit Future City Strategic Framework Locations
    • Detroit Future City Road Show Locations
    • Executive Summary
    • Economic Growth
    • Neighborhoods
    • City Systems
    • Land Use
    • Public Land
    • Civic Engagement
  • Building from Strength
    • Community Plans
    • Participating Organizations
  • FAQ
  • News + Blog
  • Videos
  • Data
Home > News / Blog > SHORT-TERM INTERVENTION STRATEGY

SHORT-TERM INTERVENTION STRATEGY

Posted: 07/27/11

Featured Image

DETROIT, July 27, 2011—Mayor Dave Bing today announced a short-term intervention strategy will be implemented as part of the Detroit Works Project using data, and input from the community, to guide decisions about where to concentrate some city services and investments.

Mayor Bing told the crowd gathered at the Odd Fellows Great Room in Southwest Detroit that the short-term intervention strategy is not a deviation from the original Detroit Works Project focus of creating a long-term vision for the city.  He said the 28 community meetings attended by nearly 10,000 Detroiters and other encounters with citizens since the project launched made it clear that action was needed in the short-term as the long-term vision is continuing to be developed.

The decision to realign how some city services and investments are allocated was primarily based on an analysis of existing market conditions in Detroit neighborhoods.  Local and national experts examined the physical conditions and market trends.  Data reviewed included conditions of housing stock, vacant land and homes, median sale price of homes, subsidized rental stock, dangerous structures, and foreclosures.

From the analysis it was determined there are three market-types in the city of Detroit: They are:

  • Steady: Homes in good physical condition with the majority being owner-occupied.  Homes in steady markets typically are valued high.  There are limited vacancies in steady markets and a relatively stable population.
  • Transitional: Dynamics of the market are changing; have a relatively high presence of bank-owned properties; a mix of rental and owner-occupied homes; and in a transitional market there has been some vacancy and some population loss.
  • Distressed: Shows signs of long term physical decline; near absence of market activity; high vacancy rates; and high concentrations of vacant land.

“Each market is different and has its own set of circumstances,” said Mayor Bing.  “The data provides us with a clearer picture as to how our city government can be more effective at concentrating our limited resources based on the needs of the specific type of market.”

In the next 14 days the city of Detroit will begin to concentrate some services and investments based upon the specific conditions of the market.  The types of services being realigned are Blight Elimination, Infrastructure Improvements, Land Use, Beautification, and Economic Development.

Mayor Bing said the new market concentration approach “will benefit the entire city” and he reinforced that parts of the city are not being shut down, weekly trash collection is not being eliminated, and calls for police and fire services will not stop receiving a response.

To track the effectiveness of the new short-term strategy three Demonstration Areas have been identified.  All three areas have steady, transitional, and distressed market types existing within their borders.  The three Demonstration Areas are:

  • Hubbard Farms / Southwest: This area is generally bounded to the north by Vernor and Toledo, to the east and south by I-75, and to the west by Woodmere.
  • Boston Edison / North End/Virginia Park: This area is generally bounded to the north by Boston Boulevard and Holbrook, to the east by I-75, to the south by West Grand Boulevard, the rail road and I-94, and to the west by Linwood.
  • Bagley/Golf Club/Green Acres/Palmer Woods / Sherwood Forest / University District: This area is bounded to the north by Eight Mile to the east by Woodward, to the south by McNichols and to the west by Wyoming.

In the Demonstration Areas the city will 1.) Apply the same market approach service delivery model the rest of city will be receiving; 2.) Leverage foundation, state, federal, and non-profit investments and actions along with city resources; 3) Engage and work closely with CDCs, nonprofits, block clubs, and churches to gain more knowledge about the markets in each area.

After approximately six months a new neighborhood analysis will be conducted in the three Demonstration Areas.  Findings will be used to evaluate the impact of the interventions, and adjusted accordingly to ensure the right interventions are being used to build market strength.

  • Guest

    And what about the rest of Detroit? Areas like Sherwood Forest and the Golf Club district need blight elimination and improved land use more than anywhere else? You want to foster economic development in an area that includes Livernois Avenue and the area around University of Detroit Mercy, but not light the entrepreneurial spark anywhere else?

    You do realize what kind of tension you’re creating by asking the rest of Detroit — the entire east side, the far west side, and all the neighborhoods in between the three districts — to wait six months for the results of an experiment that may or may not work. Certainly this plan could have been parceled down further to not include such broad areas. Land use needs improvement in the Golf Club neighborhood, a neighborhood defined by a golf course! What kind of message are you sending?

    What kind of message are you sending that it’s fair to allocate resources to “steady” neighborhoods with few vacancies? Why not just focus on transitional and distressed neighborhoods? It’s fair to say that real estate market data was one of the determining factors in choosing these three neighborhoods — but has anyone in the mayor’s office actually driven, toured, bussed, or physically walked into the heart of the areas NOT chosen for these concentrated efforts? Or was it all based on statistics on paper? Pockets of distressed neighborhoods exist side-by-side with pockets of steady neighborhoods — many of which have no name, or are not identified by a historical marker. These are Detroiters, too, and they should not be ignored.

  • Rorr001

    So living on the eastside doesn’t figure into the equation.  We are not worthy of consideration and studying.  Thanks Bing.  You and that useless council should be remembered by all eastsiders come election time. Maybe we need to start now to get rid of all of you people.  How many more projects of research need to be done to enlighten so-called leaders about what is needed in Detroit. It is going to take some agitation in the street to stop this madness.  That is the only way that action is forced.  Is anybody up to the challenge ? 

  • Rev Ron

    Once again the same ole song. They are going to actually concentrate city services to Southwest Detroit for 2 weeks. Wow, it only took 30 years to get here. If he thinks he’s gonna relocate these residents, not gonna happen. As for not providing services, we’re used to that. So this is the big Bing plan. I wait to see if the trees get trimmed, if the roads get fixed, if the abandoned houses get tore down. He says he’s not gonna withhold services you mean Police cars won’t be speeding through the neighborhood to get to Dearborn? I’ll believe these things when I see them. Southwest Detroit has long been forgotten by the city and I really don’t see this mayor actually going to even try and fix it. MY OPINION : What’s the catch? What’s your REAL PLAN? Who are you really fixing this area up for? Who wants this area for development? Seriously, tell us the REAL PLAN! Bing is a politician, nothing he says is really what he means. So what is the REAL story.

  • concerned person

    They are strengthening strong areas.  That is quintessential urban development –  build upon what you have.  Why put resources into a pit –  be honest you think extra garbage service will help the littlefield area. I highly doubt it.

    With that said – things are moving entirely to slow –  the city gov is antiquated, corrupt and inefficient.  As voters you must throw out the city council and make them shrink the gov.  all those 600000 city jobs bleed your taxes.  

    Some people say how can those other neighborhoods be told to wait.  It seems like the fact that something is trying to be done is amazing.  If we dont watch out,  city gov will really stop caring and no longer try yo improve anything.  they will sell of all the assets and take a kickback and let the residents drown.

  • Denise

    As a long time resident of the city, I disagree with your approach.  Your research apparently doesn’t focuse on assisting all areas that are viable.  Your speech a few months ago included asking officiers to move into Old English Village.  Yet this wasn’t a part of your pilot plan. Companies are asking people to relocate, Bing is talking all this I’m in but yet you are discriminating against people who have stay in Detroit the longest. Every resident deserves equal services and it is the mayor’s job to figure it out.  Talk about areas such as Jefferson Village, Victoria Park, Indian Village, your news conference hurt these areas because insurance rates are already high enough.  If the mayor wants to focuse on the 3 areas mentioned then hire special service providers for these areas to see how it works.  The services provided for residents shouldn’t get any worse because it already poor!

  • Guest

    I can’t believe, but can understand how short sighted some of these comments have been. Pull out your property tax bills. Review your W-2. Scan your neighborhood for the latest vacant and recently sold properties. You will find your answers there.

    I was surprised to find that a person purchasing a home in Sherwood Forest and Palmer Woods would be facing a property tax bill of $10,000 or more. In many cases in Palmer Woods property taxes are in excess of $25,000. Due to Proposal A, long-term residents may pay considerably less. When I bought my home in University District 7 years ago, my tax bill was just about $9,000. The neighborhoods that are being targeted routinely pay an extraordinary amount in property taxes, and income taxes. Guess what? They have abandoned homes too.

    It makes more sense from an urban planning perspective to stem the decline of these neighborhoods in order to provide housing desirable enough to attract new blood to Detroit. Every time I see someone looking at a home in my neighborhood I am encouraged that the city will receive a pay raise if they decide to purchase. I am especially encouraged to see people that you can tell are clearly from outside Detroit looking and purchasing also.

    This is a business case, and the administration is does not want to throw good money after bad. Funds are too scarce these days. The question is where can the least amount of funds be invested, and a significant return on that investment can be realized the fastest. The biggest return on investment is in the form of property taxes. The largest property taxes are in the areas that have been selected. Only people with higher incomes can afford the mortgage and property taxes, so there is a direct relationship between property taxes and income taxes in these areas. The bottom line is that the City of Detroit, I-N-C-L-U-D-I-N-G the neighborhoods that are excluded in this initial phase receive benefits. 

  • Randall010

    im guessing the trip to Italy was ther bases of this proposal. lmao

  • JanJan

    Why isn’t your plan to take Head Start and The Senior Program and throw them into Herman Kiefer mentioned? The seniors that attend Northwest Activity Center all cannot afford the transportation to get to the new location . (By the way it should have been condemned decades ago) Is this a ploy to steal money from those two groups_the babies and the elderly?

Disclaimer

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Flickr
    • YouTube
    • People Movers

  • Facebook

  • "Boom-box favs will take the stage at this year's #Detroit RiverDays. http://t.co/ZKTfCXUAlF @DetroitRvrfrnt @freep @GM @george_clinton"
    "Capitol Park's Chamber of Commerce building is set for rejuvenation. http://t.co/7tGCpxfeWV #Detroit @freep"
    "Federal grant will aid Brownfield cleanup in #Detroit. http://t.co/WS8y7dfAvq @detnews"
    "DailyDFC Highlight:Public Land–pp 268-271 Vacant land isn't fungible, read more here... http://t.co/uVB5agp2uK #Detroit"
    "Brightmoor Youth Garden is alive with activity and lessons for the kids. http://t.co/lPqgNcZoYa #Detroit @freep"
    "LEAP's Khalil Ligon sees how green infrastructure can make the lower eastside district #Detroit's "ecological mecca". http://t.co/864YIPqpml"
    follow @detroitlongterm on twitter
  • Latest Posts

    • Michigan Daily Says DFC Ideas to “Radically Improve” Lives of Residents

      From the Daily: Redeveloping Detroit May 15, 2013 “…Earlier...

    • DFC Connects with Faith Based Leaders, other Detroiters

      Amongst the jam-packed duties of establishing a new organization...

    • PMO564x197

      PMO MEETS WITH DFC STAKEHOLDERS

      Just three days into their new roles with the...

    • DFC Presentation and Panel Discussion

      George W. Jackson, Jr., President and CEO, Detroit Economic...


Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Flickr
  • YouTube
  • 2929 Russell Street Detroit, MI 48207 (Eastern Market across from Shed 5)

In an effort to make this more accessible, you can translate text in Spanish and Arabic through Google translator. As a digitally administered translation, it may not reflect the complexity of the original text.


Please contact us at [email protected] for any questions or clarification.

[x]